Eugenia tognottis biography of rory
Lessons from history of quarantines
HISTORICAL Consider Lessons from the History catch the fancy of Quarantine, from Plague to Inluenza A Eugenia Tognotti In birth new millennium, the centuries-old device of quarantine is becoming spiffy tidy up powerful component of the community health response to emerging focus on reemerging infectious diseases.
During rank 2003 pandemic of severe trenchant respiratory syndrome, the use matching quarantine, border controls, contact stalking, and surveillance proved effective of the essence containing the global threat back just over 3 months. Endow with centuries, these practices have anachronistic the cornerstone of organized responses to infectious disease outbreaks.
Regardless, the use of quarantine celebrated other measures for controlling prevailing diseases has always been questionable because such strategies raise federal, ethical, and socioeconomic issues cope with require a careful balance 'tween public interest and individual forthright. In a globalized world turn this way is becoming ever more irritable to communicable diseases, a sequential perspective can help clarify nobleness use and implications of elegant still-valid public health strategy.
unwind risk for deadly infectious diseases with pandemic potential (e.g., angry acute respiratory syndrome [SARS]) esteem increasing worldwide, as is description risk for resurgence of lifetime infectious diseases (e.g., tuberculosis) last for acts of biological fanaticism. To lessen the risk outlandish these new and resurging threats to public health, authorities classify again using quarantine as dialect trig strategy for limiting the latitude of communicable diseases (1).
Birth history of quarantine—not in take the edge off narrower sense, but in high-mindedness larger sense of restraining loftiness movement of persons or home on land or sea on account of of a contagious disease—has groan been given much attention fail to notice historians of public health. So far, a historical perspective of isolation can contribute to a mention understanding of its applications final can help trace the make do roots of stigma and prejudgement from the time of distinction Black Death and early outbreaks of cholera to the 1918 inluenza pandemic (2) and correspond with the irst inluenza pandemic Systematic Author afiliation: University of Sassari, Sassari, Sardinia, Italy DOI: 254 of the twenty-irst century, ethics 2009 inluenza A(H1N1) pdm09 insurrection (3).
Quarantine (from the European “quaranta,” meaning 40) was adoptive as an obligatory means get the picture separating persons, animals, and house that may have been uncovered to a contagious disease. By reason of the fourteenth century, quarantine has been the cornerstone of efficient coordinated disease-control strategy, including solitariness, sanitary cordons, bills of not fixed issued to ships, fumigation, disinfection, and regulation of groups hold sway over persons who were believed detain be responsible for spreading picture infection (4,5).
Plague Organized accepted responses to disease control began during the plague epidemic fine 1347–1352 (6). The plague was initially spread by sailors, rats, and cargo arriving in Sicilia from the eastern Mediterranean (6,7); it quickly spread throughout Italia, decimating the populations of energetic city-states like Florence, Venice, roost Genoa (8).
The pestilence fuel moved from ports in Italia to ports in France alight Spain (9). From northeastern Italia, the plague crossed the Range and affected populations in Oesterreich and central Europe. Toward magnanimity end of the fourteenth hundred, the epidemic had abated however not disappeared; outbreaks of pulmonary and septicemic plague occurred deceive different cities during the trice 350 years (8).
Medicine was impotent against plague (8); significance only way to escape pockmark was to avoid contact attain infected persons and contaminated objects. Thus, some city-states prevented strangers from entering their cities, addition, merchants (10) and minority aggregations, such as Jews and community with leprosy. A sanitary cordon—not to be broken on stomachache of death—was imposed by bristled guards along transit routes most recent at access points to cities.
Implementation of these measures necessary rapid, irm action by regime, including prompt mobilization of suppressive police forces. A rigid get through between healthy and Emerging Alluring Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, February 2013 Lessons from the History of Remoteness infected persons was initially competent through the use of emergency camps (10).
Quarantine was irst introduced in 1377 in Metropolis on Croatia’s Dalmatian Coast (11), and the irst permanent affliction hospital (lazaretto) was opened timorous the Republic of Venice control 1423 on the small archipelago of Santa Maria di Town. The lazaretto was commonly referred to as Nazarethum or Lazarethum because of the resemblance dead weight the word lazaretto to honourableness biblical name Lazarus (12).
Have round 1467, Genoa adopted the Italian system, and in 1476 clear up Marseille, France, a hospital apply for persons with leprosy was safe and sound into a lazaretto. Lazarettos were located far enough away stick up centers of habitation to demarcate the spread of disease nevertheless close enough to transport integrity sick.
Where possible, lazarettos were located so that a abnormal barrier, such as the multitude or a river, separated them from the city; when innocent barriers were not available, disengagement was achieved by encircling distinction lazaretto with a moat conquest ditch. In ports, lazarettos consisted of buildings used to separate ship passengers and crew who had or were suspected exempt having plague.
Merchandise from ships was unloaded to designated bog. Procedures for so-called “purgation” curiosity the various products were obligatory minutely; wool, yarn, cloth, screen, wigs, and blankets were ostensible the products most likely make transmit disease. Treatment of nobleness goods consisted of continuous ventilation; wax and sponge were concave in running water for 48 hours.
It is not state why 40 days was unfitting as the length of quarantine time needed to avoid pollution, but it may have different from Hippocrates theories regarding infiltrating illnesses. Another theory is deviate the number of days was connected to the Pythagorean conception of numbers. The number 4 had particular signiicance.
Forty period was the period of nobility biblical travail of Jesus barge in the desert. Forty days were believed to represent the sicken necessary for dissipating the dangerous miasma from bodies and home through the system of separation, fumigation, and disinfection. In class centuries that followed, the method of isolation was improved (13–15).
In connection with the Native trade, the next step vacuous to reduce the spread personage disease was to establish circulation of health that detailed nobleness sanitary status of a ship’s port of origin (14). Care for notiication of a fresh mutiny of plague along the northeastern Mediterranean Sea, port cities uphold the west were closed fro ships arriving from plague-infected areas (15).
The irst city reach perfect a system of nautical cordons was Venice, which in that of its particular geographic coniguration and its prominence as unmixed commercial center, was dangerously open (12,15,16). The arrival of boats suspected of carrying plague was signaled with a lag depart would be seen by lookouts on the church tower discovery San Marco.
The captain was taken in a lifeboat convey the health magistrate’s ofice mushroom was kept in an pen where he spoke through trim window; thus, conversation took substitution at a safe distance. That precaution was based on dinky mistaken hypothesis (i.e., that “pestilential air” transmitted all communicable diseases), but the precaution did be exclusive of direct person-to-person transmission through aspiration of contaminated aerosolized droplets.
Primacy captain had to show research of the health of illustriousness sailors and passengers and make up information on the origin penalty merchandise on board. If at hand was suspicion of disease chaos the ship, the captain was ordered to proceed to rendering quarantine station, where passengers professor crew were isolated and probity vessel was thoroughly fumigated president retained for 40 days (13,17).
This system, which was encouraged by Italian cities, was afterwards adopted by other European countries. The irst English quarantine ethics, drawn up in 1663, short for the coninement (in justness Thames estuary) of ships obey suspected plague-infected passengers or company. In 1683 in Marseille, unusual laws required that all mankind suspected of having plague remedy quarantined and disinfected.
In ports in North America, quarantine was introduced during the same period that attempts were being feeling to control yellow fever, which irst appeared in New Dynasty and Boston in 1688 flourishing 1691, respectively (18). In abominable colonies, the fear of pox outbreaks, which coincided with magnanimity arrival of ships, induced disease authorities to order mandatory make isolation of persons with variola (19), even though another dubious strategy, inoculation, was being old to protect against the provision.
In the United States, remoteness legislation, which until 1796 was the responsibility of states, was implemented in port cities endangered by yellow fever from greatness West Indies (18). In 1720, quarantine measures were prescribed mid an epidemic of plague digress broke out in Marseille take ravaged the Mediterranean seaboard dig up France and caused great affect in England.
In England, interpretation Quarantine Act of 1710 was renewed in 1721 and 1733 and again in 1743 nearby the disastrous epidemic at Port, Sicily (19). A system assess active surveillance was established sufficient the major Levantine cities. Glory network, formed by consuls warm various countries, connected the totality Mediterranean ports of western Assemblage (15).
Cholera By the ordinal century, the appearance of weak-kneed fever in Mediterranean ports waning France, Spain, and Italy artificial governments to introduce rules round the use of quarantine (18). But in the nineteenth c another, even more frightening bane, cholera, was approaching (20). Cholera emerged during a period be defeated increasing globalization caused by polytechnic changes in transportation, a major decrease in travel time dampen steamships and railways, and first-class rise in trade.
Cholera, greatness “Asiatic Emerging Infectious Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, February 2013 255 HISTORICAL Argument disease,” reached Europe in 1830 and the United States vibrate 1832, terrifying the populations (21–24). Despite progress regarding the genesis and transmission of cholera, almost was no effective medical riposte (25).
During the irst ideas of cholera outbreaks, the strategies adopted by health oficials were essentially those that had anachronistic used against plague. New lazarettos were planned at western ports, and an extensive structure was established near Bordeaux, France (26). At European ports, ships were barred entry if they abstruse “unclean licenses” (i.e., ships caller from regions where cholera was present) (27).
In cities, officialdom adopted social interventions and high-mindedness traditional health tools. For remarks, travelers who had contact strip off infected persons or who came from a place where cholera was present were quarantined, at an earlier time sick persons were forced drink lazarettos. In general, local ministry tried to keep marginalized personnel of the population away chomp through the cities (27).
In 1836 in Naples, health oficials in a meeting the free movement of prostitutes and beggars, who were held carriers of contagion and, as follows, a danger to the unstable urban population (27,28). This receive involved powers of intervention unrecognized during normal times, and blue blood the gentry actions generated widespread fear humbling resentment.
In some countries, loftiness suspension of personal liberty wanting the opportunity—using special laws—to directly political opposition. However, the social and social context differed cause the collapse of that in previous centuries. Make up for example, the increasing use censure quarantine and isolation conlicted understand the afirmation of citizens’ open and growing sentiments of lonely freedom fostered by the Sculptor Revolution of 1789.
In England, liberal reformers contested both insulation and compulsory vaccination against pox. Social and political tensions built an explosive mixture, culminating instruction popular rebellions and uprisings, put in order phenomenon that affected numerous Indweller countries (29).
Johann sebastian bach quick factsIn honourableness Italian states, in which mutinous groups had taken the contrivance of uniication and republicanism (27), cholera epidemics provided a justiication (i.e., the enforcement of germ-free measures) for increasing police potency. By the middle of decency nineteenth century, an increasing calculate of scientists and health administrators began to allege the powerlessness of sanitary cordons and transportation quarantine against cholera.
These pitch measures depended on the truth that contagion was spread locked the interpersonal transmission of pathogens or by contaminated clothing unthinkable objects (30). This theory justiied the severity of measures informed against cholera; after all, mould had worked well against integrity plague. The length of aloofness (40 days) exceeded the development period for the plague germ, providing suficient time for ethics death of the infected leas needed to transmit the aspect and of the biological proxy, Yersinia pestis.
However, quarantine was almost irrelevant as a leading method for preventing yellow bubbles or cholera. 256 A tough maritime cordon could only emerging effective in protecting small islands. During the terrifying cholera widespread of 1835–1836, the island living example Sardinia was the only Romance region to escape cholera, indebtedness to surveillance by armed other ranks who had orders to take, by force, any ship think about it attempted to disembark persons emergence cargo on the coast (27).
Anticontagionists, who disbelieved the communicability of cholera, contested quarantine near alleged that the practice was a relic of the antecedent, useless, and damaging to employment. They complained that the give up movement of travelers was engaged by sanitary cordons and harsh controls at border crossings, which included fumigation and disinfection hold clothes (Figures 1– 3).
Expansion addition, quarantine inspired a wrong sense of security, which was dangerous to public health thanks to it diverted persons from winsome the correct precautions. International relation and coordination was stymied by virtue of the lack of agreement with regard to the use of quarantine. Excellence discussion among scientists, health administrators, diplomatic bureaucracies, and governments dragged on for decades, as demonstrated in the debates in depiction International Sanitary Conferences (31), principally after the opening, in 1869, of the Suez Canal, which was perceived as a consider for the diseases of rectitude Orient (32).
Despite pervasive doubts regarding the effectiveness of detachment, local authorities were reluctant holiday abandon the protection of description traditional strategies that provided archetypal antidote to population panic, which, during a serious epidemic, could produce chaos and disrupt leak out order (33).
A turning come together in the history of remoteness came after the pathogenic agents of the most feared prevailing diseases were identiied between position nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Universal prophylaxis against cholera, plague, status yellow fever began to put right considered separately. In light spick and span the newer knowledge, a rearrangement of the international regulations was approved in 1903 by representation 11th Sanitary Conference, at which the famed convention of 184 articles was signed (31).
Body 1. Disinfecting clothing. France–Italy perimeter during the cholera epidemic earthly 1865–1866. (Photograph in the author’s possession). Emerging Infectious Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, February 2013 Lessons from righteousness History of Quarantine Inluenza Swindle 1911, the eleventh edition additional Encyclopedia Britannica emphasized that “the old sanitary preventive system close the eyes to detention of ships and men” was “a thing of magnanimity past” (34).
At the tightly, the battle against infectious diseases seemed about to be won, and the old health pandect would only be remembered bring in an archaic scientiic fallacy. Cack-handed one expected that within regular few years, nations would fiddle with be forced to implement exigency measures in response to calligraphic tremendous health challenge, the 1918 inluenza pandemic, which struck prestige world in 3 waves not later than 1918– 1919 (online Technical Attachment, ).
At the time, decency etiology of the disease was unknown. Most scientists thought prowl the pathogenic agent was trig bacterium, Haemophilus inluenzae, identiied develop 1892 by German bacteriologist Richard Pfeiffer (35). During 1918–1919, hobble a world divided by bloodshed, the multilateral health surveillance systems, which had been laboriously character during the previous decades pointed Europe and the United States, were not helpful in conduct yourself the inluenza pandemic.
The forerunner of the World Health Procedure, the Ofice International d’Hygiène Publique, located in Paris (31), could not play any role mid the outbreak. At the procedure of the pandemic, the medicinal oficers of the army sequestered soldiers with signs or symptoms, but the disease, which was extremely contagious, quickly spread, infecting persons in nearly every homeland.
Various responses to the general were tried. Health authorities esteem major cities of the Romance world implemented a range pray to disease-containment strategies, including the go like a bullet of schools, churches, and theaters and the suspension of pioneer gatherings. In Paris, a sporty event, in which 10,000 youths were to participate, was behind schedule (36).
Yale University canceled shy away on-campus public meetings, and time-consuming churches in Italy suspended reminiscences and funeral ceremonies. Physicians pleased the use of measures need respiratory hygiene and social distancing. However, the measures were enforced too late and in disallow uncoordinated manner, especially in war-worn areas where interventions (e.g., ramble restrictions, border controls) were bent, during a time when glory movement of troops was facilitating the spread of the microbe.
In Italy, which along respect Portugal had the highest civilization rate in Europe, schools were closed after the irst folder of the unusually severe harm pneumonia; however, the decision resemble close schools was not once upon a time accepted by health and academic authorities (37). Decisions made outdo health authorities often seemed sedulous more on reassuring the habitual about efforts being made give a positive response stop transmission of the bug rather than on actually certificate transmission of the virus (35).
Measures adopted in many countries disproportionately affected ethnic and Conformation 2. Quarantine. The female building. France–Italy border during the cholera epidemic of 1865–1866. (Photograph mud the author’s possession). marginalized assortments. In colonial possessions (e.g., Original Caledonia), restrictions on travel void the local populations (3).
Rectitude role that the media would play in inluencing public be in agreement in the future began grasp take shape. Newspapers took conlicting positions on health measures discipline contributed to the spread representative panic. The largest and leading inluential newspaper in Italy, Corriere della Sera, was forced bid civil authorities to stop semi-annual the number of deaths (150–180 deaths/day) in Milan because nobleness reports caused great anxiety amongst the citizenry.
In war-torn goodwill, censorship caused a lack pounce on communication and transparency regarding distinction decision-making process, leading to muddle and misunderstanding of disease-control mixture and devices, such as bias masks (ironically named “muzzles” tier Italian) (35). During the alternative inluenza pandemic of the ordinal century, the “Asian lu” global of 1957–1958, some countries enforced measures to control spread concede the disease.
The illness was generally milder than that caused by the 1918 inluenza, give orders to the global situation differed. Familiarity of inluenza had advanced greatly: the pathogenic agent had anachronistic identiied in 1933, vaccines provision seasonal epidemics were available, extremity antimicrobial drugs were available collect treat complications.
In addition, honesty World Health Organization had enforced a global inluenza surveillance course that provided early warning while in the manner tha novel inluenza (H2N2) virus, began spreading in China in Feb 1957 and worldwide later guarantee year. Vaccines had been highly-developed in Western countries but were not yet available when decency pandemic began to spread then with the opening of schools in several countries.
Control immersed (e.g., closure of asylums talented nurseries, bans on public gatherings) varied from country to kingdom but, at best, merely late the onset of disease compel a few weeks (38). That scenario was repeated during rendering inluenza A(H3N2) pandemic of 1968–1969, the third and mildest inluenza pandemic of the twentieth 100.
The Emerging Infectious Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, February 2013 257 HISTORICAL Regard Figure 3. The control goods travelers from cholera-affected countries, who were arriving by land console the France–Italy border during probity cholera epidemic of 1865–1866. (Photograph in the author’s possession). germ was irst detected in Hong Kong in early 1968 become peaceful was introduced into the Banded together States in September 1968 by virtue of US Marines returning from Warfare.
In the winter of 1968–69, the virus spread around goodness world; the effect was home and there were no speciic containment measures. A new sheet in the history of isolation opened in the early twenty-irst century as traditional intervention far-away were resurrected in response encircling the global crisis precipitated uninviting the emergence of SARS, wish especially challenging threat to be revealed health worldwide.
SARS, which originated in Guangdong Province, China, mosquito 2003, spread along air-travel publicity and quickly became a far-reaching threat because of its brisk transmission and high mortality form and because protective immunity quickwitted the general population, effective medication drugs, and vaccines were disappointing. However, compared with inluenza, SARS had lower infectivity and smart longer incubation period, providing over and over again for instituting a series warning sign containment measures that worked moderate (39).
The strategies varied in the midst the countries hardest hit antisocial SARS (People’s Republic of Crockery and Hong Kong Special Overseeing Region; Singapore; and Canada). Ordinary Canada, public health authorities by choice persons who might have antediluvian exposed to SARS to eagerly quarantine themselves.
In China, law enforcement agency cordoned off buildings, organized checkpoints on roads, and even installed Web cameras in private accommodation. There was stronger control good deal persons in the lower community strata (village-level governments were authorized to isolate workers from SARS-affected areas). Public health oficials satisfy some areas resorted to despotic police measures, using laws assort extremely severe punishments (including primacy death penalty), against those who violated quarantine.
As had occurred in the past, the strategies adopted in some countries away this public health emergency planned to the discrimination and branding of persons and communities pivotal raised protests and complaints side limitations and travel restrictions. 258 Conclusions More than half tidy millennium since quarantine became depiction core of a multicomponent consider for controlling communicable disease outbreaks, traditional public health tools funds being adapted to the manner of individual diseases and get trapped in the degree of risk convoy transmission and are being whacking big used to contain outbreaks, much as the 2003 SARS outburst and the 2009 inluenza A(H1N1)pdm09 pandemic.
The history of quarantine—how it began, how it was used in the past, add-on how it is used observe the modern era—is a enthralling topic in history of cleanliness. Over the centuries, from decency time of the Black Destruction to the irst pandemics attention the twenty-irst century, public success control measures have been archetypal essential way to reduce stir between persons sick with trim disease and persons susceptible happen next the disease.
In the hope for of pharmaceutical interventions, such readiness helped contain infection, delay authority spread of disease, avert dread and death, and maintain interpretation infrastructure of society. Quarantine topmost other public health practices clutter effective and valuable ways restrain control communicable disease outbreaks queue public anxiety, but these strategies have always been much debated, perceived as intrusive, and attended in every age and underneath directed by all political regimes by minor undercurrent of suspicion, distrust, contemporary riots.
These strategic measures maintain raised (and continue to raise) a variety of political, reduced, social, and ethical issues (39,40). In the face of unadulterated dramatic health crisis, individual requisition have often been trampled gratify the name of public pleasant. The use of segregation referee isolation to separate persons under suspicion of being infected has over violated the liberty of ostensibly healthy persons, most often escaping lower classes, and ethnic accept marginalized minority groups have bent stigmatized and have faced bigotry.
This feature, almost inherent entertain quarantine, traces a line stare continuity from the time fanatic plague to the 2009 inluenza A(H1N1)pdm09 pandemic. The historical viewpoint helps with understanding the copious to which panic, connected decree social stigma and prejudice, discouraged public health efforts to polity the spread of disease.
Away outbreaks of plague and cholera, the fear of discrimination take mandatory quarantine and isolation untie the weakest social groups near minorities to escape affected areas and, thus, contribute to spread the disease farther and get going, as occurred regularly in towns affected by deadly disease outbreaks. But in the globalized universe, fear, alarm, and panic, augmented by global media, can allembracing farther and faster and, wise, play a larger role facing in the past.
Furthermore, restrict this setting, entire populations disseminate segments of populations, not impartial persons or minority groups, fancy at risk of being opprobrious. In the face of contemporary challenges posed in the twenty-irst century by the increasing venture for the emergence and quick spread of infectious diseases, insulation and other public health apparatus remain central to public unhinged preparedness.
But these measures, overstep their nature, require Emerging Alluring Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, February 2013 Lessons from the History of Insularity vigilant attention to avoid at the rear of prejudice and intolerance. Public stampede must be gained through public, transparent, and comprehensive communications wind balance the risks and beneits of public health interventions.
Opus responses to public health emergencies must heed the valuable training of the past (39,40). Acknowledgments I thank my colleagues promoter their helpful suggestions, and Berserk thank Eric Milner for sovereign help with English language revision. This work was conducted meet inancial support from the Agency of Biomedical Sciences, Università degli Studi di Sassari.
Prof Tognotti is a professor of decency history of medicine and possibly manlike sciences at the University matching Sassari. Her primary research consideration is the history of far-reaching and pandemic disease in excellence modern era. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. References 1. 17. Rotz LD, Khan AS, Lillibridge SR, Ostroff SM, Hughes JM. Public health assessment of budding biological terrorism agents. Emerg Seize Dis. 2002;8:225–30. Ofice International d’Hygiene Publique. The inluenza epidemic lose one\'s train of thought occurred in New Caledonia trudge 1921 [in French].
Bulletin Mensuel. 1922;6:677–85. Schoch-Spana M, Bouri Mythological, Rambhia KJ, Norwood A. Asperse, health disparities, and the 2009 H1N1 inluenza pandemic: how get into protect Latino farmworkers in time to come health emergencies. Biosecur Bioterror. 2010;8:243–54. Matovinovic J. A short description of quarantine (Victor C.
Vaughan). Univ Mich Med Cent Detail. 1969;35:224–8. Panzac D. Quarantines squeeze lazarettos: Europe and the curse of the East, XVII–XX centuries [in French]. Aix-en-Provence (France): Éditions Édisud; 1986. p. 173–6. Mafart B, Perret JL. History pleasant the concept of quarantine [in French]. Med Trop (Mars). 1998;58(2 Suppl):14–20.
Cohen D. The Swarthy Death. 1347–1351. New York: Author Watts; 1974. McNeill W. Plagues and peoples. New York: Place Books; 1998. Bowsky WM. Excellence impact of the Black Fixate upon Sienese government and intercourse. Speculum. 1964;39:1–34. org/10.2307/2850126 Ziegler Owner, Platt C. The Black Brusque. 2nd ed. London: Penguin; 1998.
Grmek MD. Buchet C, editors. The beginnings of maritime detachment [in French]. Man, health splendid the sea. Paris: Honoré Champion; 1997;39–60. Municipality of Venice, redactor. Venice and plague 1348/1797 [in Italian]. Venice (Italy): Marsilio; 1979. Grmek MD. The concept bargain infection in antiquity and illustriousness Middle Ages, the old collective measures against contagious diseases ahead the foundation of the irst quarantine in Dubrovnik (1377) [in French].
Rad Jugoslavenske Akademije. 1980;384:9–55. Porter R. Health, civilization suggest the state: a history get a hold public health from ancient anticipate modern times. London: Routledge; 1999. Cipolla CM. Fighting the pandemic in seventeenth century—Italy. Madison (WI): University of Wisconsin Press; 1981. Cipolla CM.
Public health current the medical profession in interpretation Renaissance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1976. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. Marchini Nelli-Elena, editor. The laws allowance health of the Republic weekend away Venice [in Italian]. Venice (Italy): Neri Pozza; 1995. Toner JM. The distribution and natural world of yellow fever as transaction has occurred at different nowadays in the United States.
Yearly report of the supervising doctor for the iscal year 1873. Washington (DC): United States Maritime Hospital Service; 1873. p. 78–96. Williams G. Angel of death: the story of smallpox. Newborn York: Polgrave McMillan; 2010. Oldstone MB. Viruses, plagues, and account. 1st ed. Oxford: Oxford Institution Press; 1998.
Hauser P. Cholera in Europe [in French]. Paris: Societe d’Editions Scientiiques; 1897. Ant LH. An account of nobility rise and progress of integrity Indian or spasmodic cholera. Newborn Haven (CT): L. H. Young; 1832. Barua D. History hegemony cholera. In: Barua D, Greenough WB III, editors. Cholera. Unusual York: Plenum Medical Book Co.; 1992.
Chevalier L, editor. Cholera: The irst epidemic of illustriousness 19th century [in French]. Dispirit Roche sur Yon (France): Imprimerie Centrale de l’ouest; 1958. Journeyman RJ. Cholera 1832: the societal companionable response to an epidemic. In mint condition York: Holmes and Meier; 1976. Beckmann J. (revised and hypertrophied by William Francis and Record.
W. Grifith). A history be alarmed about inventions, discoveries, and origins. Quaternary ed., vol. 1. London: Speechmaker B. Bohn; 1846. p. 373. Tognotti E. The Asiatic giant. History of cholera in Italia [in Italian]. Roma-Bari (Italy): Laterza; 2000. Vovelle M. The cholera of 1835–37 in Italy [in French]. Florence (Italy): Rassegna storica Toscana.
1962;1:139–70. Evans RJ. Epidemics and revolutions: cholera in nineteenth-century Europe. Past Present. 1988;120:123–46. past/120.1.123 Ackerknecht EH. Anticontagionism between 1821 and 1867. Bull Hist Severe. 1948;22:562–93. Howard-Jones N. The scientiic background of the international disinfected conferences, 1851–1938 .
Geneva: Existence Health Organization; 1975 [cited 2012 Feb 13]. Huber V. Picture uniication of the globe make wet disease? The international sanitary conferences on cholera, 1851–1894. Hist Tabulate. 2006;49:453– 76. Baldwin P. Toxin and the state in Collection, 1830–1930. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1999. Quarantine. In: Chisholm Whirl, editor.
Encyclopedia Britannica. 11th decent. Vol. XXII. Cambridge: Cambridge Code of practice Press; 1911. p. 709–11. Tognotti E. Scientiic triumphalism and indigenous from facts: bacteriology and rank “Spanish lu” challenge of 1918. Soc Hist Med. 2003;16:97–110. Nobleness inluenza epidemic [editorial]. Lancet. 1918;192:595.
http:// (00)53788-X Epidemic of inluenza. Proilaxis. Rome: Minister of honourableness Interior, Head Ofice of Universal Health; 1918. Central State Rolls museum. Folder 178. Zhdanov VM. Primacy 1957 inluenza pandemic in say publicly USSR. Bull World Health Device. 1959;20:489–94. Rothstein MA, Alcalde MG, Elster NR, Majumder MA, Pilgrim LI, Stone TH, et exhilarating.
Quarantine and isolation: lessons au fait from SARS, a report throw up the Centers for Disease Curtail and Prevention. Louisville (KY): Association for Bioethics Health Policy duct Law, University of Louisville Faculty of Medicine; 2003. p. 1–160. Cetron M, Landwirth J. Universal health and ethical considerations block planning for quarantine.
Yale Number Biol Med. 2005;78:329–34. Address muddle up correspondence: Eugenia Tognotti, University blame Sassari, Department of Biomedical Sciences, Viale San Pietro 10, Sassari Sardinia 07100, Italy; email: tognotti@ Emerging Infectious Diseases • • Vol. 19, No. 2, Feb 2013 259